
For a while now I’ve been wanting to invest in a macro lens. However, I have yet to purchase one simply because I can’t decide which one to get. After much research, I narrowed it down to the Canon 100 mm f2.8 macro and the Canon 100 mm f2.8 L macro. For the purposes of this blog post, I will just call them the “L lens” and the “non L lens”.
I decided to spend $50, rent them both and try them out to decide for myself which one is the best buy for me. The L lens is normally around $950, but Canon has a $60 rebate right now and the “non L lens” is usually around $500.
So here are some shots I took today. They are all STRAIGHT OUT OF CAMERA, but are sharpened and resized for the web.
Since I’d mostly use my macro lens to photograph rings, that’s what my subjects are for these next shots. I DID NOT use a tripod as I usually don’t use a tripod on a wedding day. To keep this an unbiased comparison for you, I won’t tell you the lenses until the end of the post. Get a pen and a piece of paper and start guessing.
f2.8, 1/125, iso 800 (yes, I moved a little)

f2.8, 1/125, iso 800, manual focus (hmm, yeah, i moved again… better start getting used to it)

f2.8, 1/80, iso 200, auto focus

f2.8, 1/60, iso 250, auto focus


f2.8, 1/160, iso 800, manual focus


Do you have all your guesses?
So here are the answers:
All of the images on the left were taken with the “non L lens”. All the images on the right were taken with the “L lens”
All of the top images were taken with the “non L lens”. All of the bottom images were taken with the “L lens”
How did you do? What do you think? Which lens would you buy?
It seems to me that the “L lens” does let a little more light in than the “non L lens” which would be great for those dark getting ready rooms :)
Also, it is worth noting that the “L lens” does have IS. I was able to handhold the “non L lens” only down to 1/40 sec and have it be completely sharp. At 1/30 sec I couldn’t handhold it anymore.
Any questions or experiments you would like to see? I only have both lenses until tomorrow.
Myrian Peery
Awesome post Cristi!
Cristiane
Loved it! Exactly what I needed to read right now! thank you for sharing!
Alicia
Thanks for putting so much work into that post Cristi. It is crazy to see how much difference there is between the two 100mm 2.8 lenses.
Our favorite lenses for our 5d are the 50mm 1.4, the 85mm 1.8 and the 70-200mm 2.8L.
Jeri
Wow! Exploring through your website and found this. Thanks! I used to be neighbors with Curtis’s family in Polson! Great photos.